legal practice

Understanding Regulatory Implications of AI in Legal Practice

Explore how evolving U.S. regulations and ethical standards are shaping the use of AI in law. Stay compliant, informed, and ready to integrate AI responsibly into your practice.
  • Joe Regalia
As artificial intelligence (AI) becomes increasingly integrated into legal practice, understanding the evolving regulatory landscape is essential for legal professionals. This guide delves into current and anticipated AI regulations in the United States, equipping lawyers to navigate compliance effectively.​

The U.S. Regulatory Landscape: A Patchwork of Approaches

In the United States, AI regulation is characterized by a combination of federal guidelines, state laws, and professional ethical standards. This multifaceted approach presents both opportunities and challenges for legal practitioners.​
At the federal level, there is no comprehensive AI-specific legislation. Instead, existing laws and regulations are applied to AI technologies. The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has been active in this area, enforcing actions against deceptive AI practices.  ​
For instance:
In September 2024, the FTC fined DoNotPay $193,000 for misleading claims about its AI-driven legal services, emphasizing the importance of substantiating AI-related assertions.
Additionally, the U.S. Senate released a bipartisan framework in August 2023, outlining principles for future AI legislation, including transparency, accountability, and the promotion of responsible AI use. ​
States have begun to address AI regulation independently, leading to a diverse array of laws. 
for example:
California's proposed SB 1047 bill aimed to impose strict regulations on AI companies, including liability for damages and a required "kill switch" for uncontrollable systems. However, Governor Gavin Newsom vetoed the bill in September 2024, citing concerns about its potential impact on innovation.
This fragmented state-level approach underscores the need for legal professionals to stay informed about jurisdiction-specific regulations.​

Ethical Considerations and Professional Responsibility

The American Bar Association (ABA) provided guidance on the ethical use of AI tools in legal practice. Formal Opinion 512, issued in July 2024, addresses key ethical obligations:​
  • Competence: Lawyers must understand the capabilities and limitations of AI tools to ensure competent representation.​

  • Confidentiality: Protecting client information is paramount, especially when using AI systems that process sensitive data.​

  • Communication: Attorneys should inform clients about the use of AI in their cases and discuss potential implications.​
The ABA emphasizes that while AI can enhance efficiency, it should not replace a lawyer's judgment and oversight. ​

Practical Steps for Legal Professionals

To navigate the AI regulatory landscape effectively, consider the following steps:
Stay Informed
Regularly update yourself on AI regulations in your jurisdiction and any regions where your clients operate.​
Assess AI Tools
Evaluate AI applications for compliance with relevant laws and ethical standards before integration into your practice.​
Implement Oversight
Establish protocols for human oversight of AI systems to ensure accountability and mitigate risks.​
Educate Clients
Inform clients about the use of AI in your services, including potential benefits and limitations.​
Engage with Professional Bodies
Participate in discussions and training offered by legal associations to stay abreast of best practices in AI usage.​
By proactively engaging with AI regulations and ethical considerations, legal professionals can harness the benefits of AI while upholding the highest standards of practice.
Joe Regalia
Write.law co-founder Joe Regalia combines his experience as both practitioner and professor to create exciting new ways to teach legal skills.  Learn more about Joe

Sign up for our newsletter!

Get writing and other legal practice tips delivered to your inbox every other Thursday.
Thanks for joining!
We’ve sent a welcome email to your inbox.